It has been 16 years since Sergio Martinez’s left hand left boxing fans around the world breathless and poor Paul Williams unconscious. It was November 20, 2010, and the Boardwalk Hall in Atlantic City fell silent for a few seconds before erupting as “Maravilla” began celebrating his successful defence of the WBC middleweight title against “The Punisher”. It was a knockout for the ages, one of the finest of the last twenty years. To mark its anniversary, let’s look back at the build-up to that eagerly anticipated rematch and its brief but astonishing conclusion.
The Controversial Decision in the First Thrilling Encounter
The two protagonists of our story had first met on December 5, 2009, in a thrilling showdown with no title at stake. Having been avoided far and wide by other world-class boxers, they had decided to put their reputations on the line in an extremely risky contest for both men. The winner would emerge as the leading contender for the middleweight crown and attract widespread media attention.
Although both men had come up from lower weight divisions, the physical disparity between them was striking inside the ring. Williams had been a genuine genetic anomaly among welterweights, standing 185 centimetres tall with an extraordinary reach of more than two metres. Martinez, by contrast, had a compact, stocky build and, standing next to his opponent, looked as though he would have to pull off the biblical feat of David vs Goliath.
A blazing opening round provided the perfect prelude to the spectacle that was to follow. Martinez went down after being caught by an awkward punch while off balance, but returned the favour by dropping his opponent with a powerful right hook just before the bell: the show was well and truly underway.
During the first half of the fight, the Punisher’s head was repeatedly jolted from side to side by the Argentine’s swinging punches. Williams then began to mount a gradual comeback through his suffocating pressure, but once again Martinez pulled ahead with his trademark second wind. Just when spectators were becoming convinced that one of the two fighters was gaining the upper hand, the other would turn things around and throw the contest wide open again.
The final rounds, fought on a knife-edge by two exhausted boxers, did little to settle the debate. The majority decision in favour of Paul Williams, which included a scandalous 119-110 scorecard, sparked considerable controversy. A rematch was inevitable.
From a Near Miss for Fight of the Year to Knockout of the Year
If the 2009 showdown between Williams and Martinez failed to win the Fight of the Year award, it was only because Juan Manuel Marquez and Juan Diaz had produced an unforgettable battle for the unified lightweight world championship that same year.
Nevertheless, there was no way anyone could deny Maravilla the Knockout of the Year award the following year, when he settled the score for that disputed decision in emphatic fashion. In between the two fights, the Argentine superstar had added another historic chapter to his career by capturing the WBC middleweight title at the expense of the gigantic Kelly Pavlik.
Having secured the coveted championship belt, Martinez was immediately given the opportunity to settle the unfinished business by accepting Williams’ challenge and finally determining which of the two was the better fighter.
Remarkably, despite a world title being at stake, the fight was contested at a catchweight of 158 pounds, two pounds below the middleweight limit. Even more remarkably, this clause had been included at the insistence of the towering Williams, while the much smaller Martinez had reluctantly agreed to it, explicitly stating that he would be ashamed to request a catchweight before challenging for a world title.
Inside the ring, however, those two extra pounds did not seem to make much difference… After an opening round in which he looked faster and sharper than his opponent, the champion produced his masterpiece: a perfectly timed left hand that landed flush on Williams’ chin and left him unable to recover for several minutes.
Sadly, life dealt The Punisher an even harsher blow than Maravilla’s left hand when, following a serious car accident, the American fighter was left paralysed from the waist down and forced to use a wheelchair. But, true to the indomitable warrior he has always been, Williams found the strength to keep smiling and remained involved in the world of sport that had made him famous, taking up a coaching role.
